Student witnesses described deadly confrontation
By: Chase Rogers, Jamie Landers
Staff Writers
McKINNEY — Jurors on Friday got their first glimpse of the pocketknife prosecutors say Karmelo Anthony used to fatally stab Austin Metcalf.
Collin County Assistant District Attorney Bill Wirskye pulled on black gloves to display the knife: A 3.5-inch black blade with a textured silver handle, small enough to fit in a palm and to legally carry on school grounds in Texas.
The outcome of the case could hinge on how the jury views the weapon, and whether they believe Anthony’s decision to use it on the unarmed Metcalf was justified.
Student-athletes who saw the incident unfold testified that Anthony, now 19, had his hand in a backpack before the altercation. They said they thought he was bluffing and were shocked when he pulled out the knife.
“No one brings a knife to a track meet,” a 16-year-old student-athlete testified under questioning from Wirskye. District Judge John Roach Jr. forbade media outlets from naming him or other minors called as witnesses.
The case, which has drawn national attention, racially charged demonstrations and online animus, centers on a dispute last year that began when Metcalf and others told Anthony to leave their team’s tent during a rain-delayed high school track meet in Frisco.
Anthony’s attorneys have argued he acted in self-defense, making a split-second decision in the face of a threat from teenagers who were taller and larger than he was. Prosecutors say Anthony baited Metcalf into the altercation as a pretext to use the knife.
Earlier in the day, jurors watched an officer’s body-worn camera footage from the moments after the stabbing, showing paramedics tending to Metcalf as he lay motionless at the base of the metal stands.
The judge allowed a prolonged break after the video was played, he said, because it made one juror feel sick.
Student witnesses with differing accounts have same conclusion
Friday’s testimony moved closer to the confrontation under the Frisco Memorial High School tent.
In a demonstration for the jury, one of Anthony’s defense attorneys, Toby Shook, sat in a chair in the middle of the courtroom to allow the 16-year-old to reenact the moment Metcalf was stabbed.
The student, standing over Shook, placed a hand on Shook’s right shoulder. At the same time, Shook, portraying Anthony, stood up, simultaneously acting out a stabbing motion on the student’s upper chest.
Because he had moved toward Anthony to shove him, the student said, Metcalf was leaning into Anthony when the stabbing occurred, and fell backward directly after.
Metcalf, another student testified, fell down the bleachers, landing on his back. He stood up briefly, lifting his shirt to find his chest covered in blood.
Each subsequent student who testified shared slightly differing memories of the moments leading up to the stabbing.
Jalen Matthews, who graduated from Frisco Memorial earlier this year, described Anthony as being “half in, half out” of the tent, recalling the awning didn’t quite cover Anthony enough to shield him from the rain.
Matthews, 18, described Anthony and Metcalf’s interaction as tense, finding them both more frustrated than angry. Matthews said he noticed Anthony’s hands were in his backpack, but said no one expected the exchange to turn violent.
A 17-year-old student who took the stand said Anthony was not sitting under Memorial’s tent, but rather directly behind it. The student said several people told Anthony to leave more than a dozen times.
If he wasn’t under the tent, what was the problem with that?” Shook asked the 17-year-old during cross-examination.
“Relative area,” the student said.
The 16-year-old student said Metcalf used one hand — not two — to shove Anthony in the seconds before he was stabbed.
Each student was asked whether Anthony provoked Metcalf.
They all identified Anthony as the aggressor and said they did not believe the stabbing was an act of self-defense.
Officer who detained Anthony testifies
Eduardo Cortez, a school resource officer assigned to Frisco ISD’s Staley Middle School, testified that he ran to the nearby stadium after hearing a radio call about a stabbing. Cortez said he located Anthony and placed him in handcuffs.
Under questioning from Wirskye, he said Anthony did not try to run.
During cross-examination, Anthony’s lead defense attorney, Mike Howard, honed in on his client’s demeanor, noting he could have refused to give his name or given a false one when detained. Cortez agreed the teenager was cooperative.
Wirskye presented a replica of the knife to the jury while questioning Frisco police officer Jacob Shalz, who secured the scene and collected evidence on the day of the stabbing.
When Shalz passed to Howard for cross-examination, Howard asked the officer if he was aware that while a knife under 5 and a half inches may violate school policy, it’s not a crime.
“Yes, sir,” Shalz affirmed.
Texas law does not ban every knife from school campuses or school-sponsored events. Criminal charges apply to what the law refers to as “location-restricted knives,” defined as one with a blade longer than 5 and a half inches.
Eric Ruben, a Southern Methodist University law professor who studies weapons regulations and how they intersect with self-defense laws, said the lawfulness of a weapon is often a separate question from whether someone was justified in using it.
Ruben said that in cases with self-defense claims, the use of a weapon can raise questions about why the defendant had it and whether they were looking for a fight.
“It speaks to the reasonableness, it speaks to state of mind,” he said, “and that’s incredibly important in a self-defense case when the jury has to decide whether the threat perception was reasonable and whether the response was reasonably believed to be necessary and proportionate.”
The trial is set to resume at 9 a.m. Saturday.
Public Safety Reporter
Chase Rogers covers the Dallas Police Department, Dallas Fire-Rescue, and broader public safety issues in Dallas. He grew up in Granbury and studied journalism at Texas State University in San Marcos. Before joining The News, he reported for the Austin American-Statesman and the Corpus Christi Caller-Times. His work has earned investigative reporting and Freedom of Information awards, including Texas Managing Editor’s Star Reporter of the Year in 2022. He can be reached at 361-239-6527 and on Signal at crogers.95.
Senior Breaking News Reporter
Jamie Landers is the senior breaking news reporter at The Dallas Morning News, where she covers crime, courts and capital punishment. She is a graduate of The Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication in Phoenix, where she studied journalism and political science. Jamie previously reported for The Arizona Republic and Arizona PBS.
